Broadsides Discussion Forum

1170 posts

Broadsides ROE

Rules of Engagement (ROE)

We welcome discussion and debate on Broadsides, and we encourage contributions and opinions from a wide variety of perspectives.  NOTE #1: We ask contributors to keep the discussion civil — […]

Share

The Plan for a Stronger Canada: Naval Strategy

By Brian Santarpia, 31 October 2026 Richard Gimblett’s A Canadian Naval Strategy Reader makes an important contribution to the current discussion by placing Canadian naval strategy in its historical context. […]

Share

A New Canadian Defence Plan: Coming Soon?

By Jeff G. Gilmour, 31 October 2026 The Mobilizing Insights in Defence and Security (MINDS) Defence Challenges document, managed by DND, outlined five core policy challenges in 2019, in response […]

Share

Canadian Naval Strategy

By Moderator, 21 October 2026 Everything you’ve always wanted to know about Canadian naval strategy … but were afraid to ask. A useful new publication – “A Canadian Naval Strategy […]

Share

The Future of Asterix

By Les Mader, 14 October 2026 At the attached YouTube video, Scott Taylor of Esprit de Corps magazine argues for the RCN’s continued use of the Asterix resupply vessel even […]

Share

Defence Crown Corporation: A Solution?

By Dr. Ann Griffiths, 10 October 2026 A few days ago, the government introduced legislation – Bill C-40: Strengthening Canada’s Defence Sector — to change the Defence Investment Agency (DIA) […]

Share

Preview: Volume 22, No. 2

By Dr. Ann Griffiths, 4 October 2026 Alas, summer is over. But it’s not just snow and sleet and ice coming in the future – the fall issue of CNR […]

Share

Considering Arctic Amphibious Ships

By Les Mader, 30 September 2026 Comments made over the years here in the Broadsides Forum and by some individuals connected with Canadian Naval Review have led me to understand […]

Share

Two fleets need one maritime picture

By Al Vigier, 18 September 2026 Canada has ordered P-8A Poseidons and is negotiating for GlobalEyes. Both should improve what our navy can see. The useful question is how much […]

Share

Brazil’s Increased Military Spending

By Jeff Gilmour, 15 September 2026 In the 1970s, apparently Brazil launched and abandoned at least three warship programs.[1] In April this year, however, it commissioned a new frigate, Tamandare, […]

Share

USS Abraham Lincoln Saga

By Poseidon, 8 September 2026 There was a huge amount of adverse publicity recently in the media stemming from complaints from some members of the crew of the aircraft carrier […]

Share

The PLA(N)’s Third Fleet

By Jeff Gilmour, 26 August 2026 An article (“Out of the Shadows”) published in The Economist in July reported that last December, over 1,000 fishing vessels from China’s eastern seaboard […]

Share

Building Upon Sovereign Under-Ice Power

By Lee Matheson, 23 August 2026 Canada has selected TKMS and its Type-212CD AIP/lithium battery submarine as preferred supplier for the Canadian Patrol Submarine Project. AIP is a game changer […]

Share

Summer Activity in the Arctic

By Moderator, 16 August 2026 In a news release 14 August, the Department of National Defence announced the launch of Operation Nanook-Tuugaalik 2026, a part of the annual Operation Nanook. The […]

Share

RCN Leadership Changes

By Dr. Ann Griffiths, 14 August 2026 In case you haven’t been paying attention, there have been some changes to the RCN leadership. Vice-Admiral Angus Topshee, who was Commander of […]

Share

Strategy for Submarines?

By Moderator, 31 July 2026 At the beginning of July Prime Minister Mark Carney announced the winning bid for the construction of (up to) 12 submarines — the German-Norwegian consortium […]

Share